May 19, 2009 7:15:35 PM EST
Some people may think I'm naive, but generally I think honesty and humility shine through (no, it's not a religious thing...). Personlally I don't think there is anything wrong with reviewing your own wine (or anything else you do for that matter) as long as you are honest with yourself. Some people may not appreciate wineries critiquing their own wines, but in the end those people will make their own judgement about how valid they think the review is based on the information to hand.
It is difficult to make an informed decision about a particluar wine based on one review alone. But as more and more reviews are posted on the site over time, a clear picture should emerge of the general consensus. That's where I think the value in BoozeMonkey's wine reviews lies. That, and following a particular reviewer whose tastes are similar to your own and whose opinion you trust based on past reviews.
The more reviews we have on the site the better, so when you try a bottle of wine, whether it was a $50 special-occasion bottle or a $3~$5 cheapie, and whether you enjoyed it or not, add a quick review so everyone can benefit from your experience. I know I would appreciate knowing which bottles you have enjoyed and which you haven't, and I'm sure I'm not alone.
